Dr. Joel Schumacher
- Maryal Concepcion
- 4 days ago
- 7 min read
DPC Doctor
Direct Primary Care (DPC) is no longer an emerging niche—it’s a transformative movement led by physicians who want purpose, autonomy, and lasting relationships at the core of their practice. For physicians looking to start, grow, or deepen their own DPC journey, there’s a wealth of best practices and cautionary tales. Few, however, are as open and relatable as the story of Dr. Joel Schumacher of Schumacher Family Medicine in Plymouth, Indiana.
On the “My DPC Story” podcast with Dr. Maryal Concepcion, Dr. Schumacher paints an honest picture of rural medicine and DPC entrepreneurship: the grind of employed practice, the prioritization of authentic patient connection, the risk and rewards of breaking free, and the fulfillment found in creating a patient- and physician-centered clinic. His case offers not only inspiration, but actionable insights for anyone considering or operating a DPC—whether in a bustling city or a two-stoplight community. Below, we’ll break down Dr. Schumacher’s journey, the decisions and strategies that made his practice thrive, and the deep lessons all DPC physicians can reflect on.
From Small Town Roots to Hospital Employment: Where the System Fails
Dr. Schumacher’s values were shaped growing up in rural Indiana—a place where relationships matter, everyone knows your name, and family is central. In medical school and residency, he realized just how different the experience of healthcare could be in tight-knit communities compared to urban systems. His attraction to family medicine was cemented by the chance to serve whole families and build real relationships.
After completing residency in 1995, Dr. Schumacher chose to join a mentor, Dr. Kent Guild, in Plymouth. He didn’t follow peers who lined up for large hospital employment offers with lucrative signing bonuses. Instead, he circled a map of Indiana, searching for towns small enough to know his neighbors but large enough to build a career. That method—values-driven, relationship-focused decision-making—would define his whole approach.
Initially, the hospital-employed model seemed to work, especially under the direct tutelage of Dr. Guild, who reminded him, “We’re here to serve.” For the first five years, the work was rewarding, patient-centered, and the hospital was hands-off. Yet, as is too often the case with system consolidation, Dr. Schumacher’s autonomy faded with every new merger. Rules, red tape, and productivity demands snowballed until the work became unsustainable: “The further you are away from the decision makers, the worse it gets.”
As the “honeymoon” wore off, joy was replaced by burnout and moral injury—entirely divorced from why he began practicing medicine.
The Decision to Leap: Burnout and Finding a Way Out
For many DPC founders, the pain point is clear: being unable to practice as you see fit, having little time with patients, and watching your own family life suffer. Dr. Schumacher describes coming home one evening, late again, to his young family nearly finished with dinner. His wife gently told him, “We’ve just kind of learned it’s easier just to go ahead and do life without you.” This moment—gut-wrenching and eye-opening—made him realize he couldn’t keep going until retirement. Yet, like so many mid-career physicians, he didn’t know what alternatives existed.
The opportunity to join a small employer-based clinic away from the hospital treadmill provided a lifeline. It was there, running near-site and on-site clinics without insurance billing, with longer patient visits, that he realized medicine could be different—fulfilling and sustainable.
Only later, as the employer clinic grew and acquired venture capital, did Dr. Schumacher stumble across the DPC movement. Here were physicians building modest, independent practices grounded in the same principles he valued. Finally, he saw a model that matched his vision—and skills.
Starting His DPC: Practical Realities and Key Choices
Site Selection and Returning “Home”
Selecting the right physical space for Schumacher Family Medicine was about more than real estate—it was a symbolic return. The practice building where Dr. Guild once practiced (and where Dr. Schumacher first shadowed as a resident) happened to become available through a serendipitous set of events. Instead of hunting endlessly for the perfect new office, he bought the now-renovated older building, benefiting from both historic resonance and affordable infrastructure.
Pre-Launch Strategies and Community Buy-In
Dr. Schumacher was strategic about building a patient panel before opening the doors. Using his local reputation, a basic website, social media, and two large “town hall” informational meetings, he sparked deep curiosity about the DPC model. By collecting enrollment fees in advance, he ensured patients had skin in the game and began with 75 committed members on Day One—a huge leap for most DPC startups.
The Value of Staff, Even Early
Although DPC often touts the benefits of micro-practice, Dr. Schumacher hired a seasoned medical assistant from Day One. Not only did this ensure smooth workflows and patient service, but it recognized his need for a collegial, relationship-rich workplace. For him, building a DPC was about connection at every level—not just between doctor and patient, but within the care team.
JOIN OUR PATREON COMMUNITY TODAY FOR EXCLUSIVE CONTENT
Scaling Thoughtfully: Growth, Boundaries, and Flexibility
Managing Rapid Expansion
Schumacher Family Medicine grew quickly—surpassing 600, then 800, and now approaching 900 patients, partly through partnerships with local employers. When a company wanted to enroll all 100 of its employees and dependents, Dr. Schumacher negotiated admission in manageable, staged groups, ensuring care remained personal and sustainable.
Crowding the panel too quickly can erode the fundamental DPC advantage of time and relationship. By setting boundaries, slowing enrollment, and adapting workflows, Dr. Schumacher protected both his practice and his patient experience—something every DPC physician should remember amid the pressure to “scale up.”
Autonomy and Saying "No"
A key lesson from Dr. Schumacher’s story is the power DPC physicians have to control their environment. From deciding how to handle insurance (or not), to communicating with employers, to making compassionate choices about after-hours contact, Dr. Schumacher shapes his practice intentionally. This isn’t about “work less, earn more”—it’s about working on your own terms, for patients, not systems.
Nurturing Relationship Over Transaction: The Core of Schumacher’s DPC
The Value Proposition That Resonates
Not every patient is first attracted by cost savings—many come for access and time. Dr. Schumacher sees, especially in the Medicare population, that patients return after tasting the five-minute visit elsewhere. DPC membership, they discover, means being heard. “Listening is powerful,” he notes. “Nobody listens to anybody anymore, it seems.” When patients are used to bureaucratic, detached care, the difference becomes a core value proposition.
Faith and Respect in Practice
Practicing in a small, primarily Christian community, Dr. Schumacher brings his worldview into conversations—but never imposes it. He’s built relationships strong enough that some patients request prayer as part of their care. Yet, he serves everyone with respect, regardless of faith, politics, or background. For DPC clinicians anywhere, the lesson is clear: Your practice should reflect your authentic self, but always respect the diverse experiences and beliefs of your patients.
Community and Collegiality
DPC has a reputation for collegial support—and Dr. Schumacher has both benefited from and contributed to this culture. He welcomes neighboring physicians, residents, and students to shadow him and explore the realities of DPC. His advice for newcomers: attend summits, reach out to practicing DPC docs, and don’t hesitate to ask questions—there’s enough to go around for everyone. These gestures multiply DPC’s impact across communities and generations.
The Next Chapter: Succession, Sustainability, and Giving Back
Dr. Schumacher is candid about the challenges of succession and aging. With thirty years in practice and a thriving DPC, he hopes someone might join his clinic or start a neighboring DPC, paving the way for smoother transitions as he reduces his workload. Recognizing that hospitals lure new grads with signing bonuses, he’s helped local businesses create a reverse scholarship fund to help cover debts for incoming DPC physicians—a powerful example of community investing in its future.
His advice to residents? If you must enter a hospital system for financial reasons, pay down debts rather than upgrading your lifestyle. Don’t let “golden handcuffs” trap you. And above all, keep sight of your reasons for pursuing medicine in the first place.
Reflective Takeaways for Your DPC Journey
Dr. Schumacher’s story offers several universal lessons for DPC (and future DPC) practitioners:
Know Your Why: Relationships, autonomy, and patient-first care cannot be overstated as motivating forces. Keep them central as you design or refine your practice.
Start Before You’re “Ready”: Perfection is the enemy of progress. Launch at 70%, and iterate as you grow.
Leverage Community Roots and Word of Mouth: Especially in rural or smaller communities, your reputation precedes you. Town halls, social media, and local events can powerfully drive early growth.
Protect Time and Boundaries: Scaling patient panels and onboarding employers can happen without sacrificing the core value of DPC—set limits, communicate them, and adjust as needed.
Choose Your Team (and Culture) Wisely: Whether micro or staffed, make hiring and partnership decisions that fit your personality, needs, and vision.
Stay Flexible and Creative: DPC allows for negotiation, custom contracts, and solutions to challenges—think beyond traditional models.
Mentor and Engage: Sharing your journey, solutions, and daily flow helps grow the movement and attracts others to sustain your practice (and sanity).
Building a Life as Well as a Practice
Dr. Schumacher’s story is proof that DPC isn’t just about health system disruption—or even about improved access for patients. It’s about restoring medicine as a calling, preserving moments with family, and creating a sustainable, joyful professional life. Every DPC journey is different, but the principles of relationship, autonomy, and purpose are universally powerful.
If you’re at a crossroads in your own DPC path, use these reflections as inspiration, a roadmap, and a gentle push: You can build a practice (and a life) true to your values—one patient, and one relationship, at a time.
Watch the Episode Here:
Listen to the Episode Here:
CONTACT/LINKS:
Dr. Schumacher Email: drjoel@schumacherfamilymedicine.com
FB: @schumacherfamilymedicine
WEBSITE: schumacherfamilymedicine.com
DON'T MISS AN EPISODE!
SUBSCRIBE TODAY!
Leave us a review in Apple Podcasts and Spotify to help others discover the pod so they can also listen to all the DPC stories so far!
WE'RE ON YOUTUBE & YOUTUBE PODCASTS!
